Most people in the College disclaim Professor Adler’s influence there. However, Professor Adler shares with Professor’s McKeon and Crane and others that preoccupation with dialectical method which renders him powerless to value prose or poetry. His inability in prose is plain from How To [13] Read a Book where reading is made an exercise in isolating the rationalistic procedures only. It is a method which necessarily ignores nine-tenths of prose. Worst of all, it compels a reader to follow bad prose just as far as good prose. But Art and Prudence exhibits this dilemma in greater profusion. Having no secure sense of the relevance of one thing rather than another– or of one book or one movie rather than another– he proceeds to give an esthetic carte blanche to all media which can lay claim even to utilizing the mechanic arts. Having discovered a valid speculative distinction between art and prudence, Professor Adler can see no more than Professor McKeon, where those activities are necessarily merged in practice. How, as R.P. Blackmur says of Henry James, art is “the viable presentation of moral value; in the degree that the report was intelligent and intense the morals were sound.” Finding in dialectics no available means of unifying the interests and experience of man and society, Professors Adler and McKeon can naturally discover no basis for fusing art and prudence.