Professor Warner Taylor is probably the only living man who could mention any difference between the diction and sentence structure of Swift and Fielding. He counts the words. But Swift’s style is worlds away from Fielding’s because Swift makes serious demands on his reader. Thus his Modest Proposal is electric with tensions between Swift and his subject and the audience. It is a work of rhetoric. That is, its purpose is not to be contemplated or explored like poetic work but to persuade, to alter opinions, to make an impact, to produce action. Swift’s “irony” in this pamphlet, as in most of his work, is to wear a mask. On the mask are the features of an earnest, methodical unimaginative and self-righteous man. He speaks as one concerned about a particular social problem. His tones are those of unimpassioned discussion. His assumptions are those of the political scientists and economists of Swift’s day. The dialectic of his discourse follows a probable path from these assumptions, and the grotesque inhumanity of the conclusions is patently in the postulates. So that the superficial peripeteia of the dialectic really directs attention throughout to the face behind the Philistine mask. That is, the face of Swift himself, contorted with rage against the smug villainy of the public-spirited men of his time. His passion is a commentary on the unimpassioned mask and on the dialectic, as well. And the pleasure of the reader is proportioned to the demands made upon him in these ways. But as the methods of Adler, McKeon, and Crane are unable to reveal the complexity of this pamphlet, they are unable to establish its style and excellence.