And since the College at Chicago, like St. John’s, shows neither awareness nor concern with the need to forge anew a unified sensibility, to restore the close harmony of thought, action, and feeling, it must be judged not as a genuinely contemporary experiment but merely a continuation of that dichotomized Cartesian culture of the Enlightenment. For it is the mark of truly contemporary minds that they are deeply aware of actual interfusion of human interests. So that since Baudelaire, the most vital contemporary culture has gained stride and momentum and, in fact, has lost the Cartesian limp. But of the new gains for cultural unity and community achieved by a Freud, a Malinowski, a Dawson, a Giedion, or a Corbusier, nothing appears at Chicago or in the great books program. Chicago persists, along with all the rest, in a naive rationalism which regards a poem, a philosophy, a building, or a political constitution as a Leibnitzian monad without windows. So that only by pre-established harmony, assured by the possession of dialectical skill, can a person and such objects ever be said to have “met”. [14] That is only another way of saying that student and teacher alike are cut off from the nutritional properties of art and civilization. Thus, the dilemma is precisely that of the ordinary man in relation to a commercial job today. Abstract commerce and dialectical education are the outside and inside of the same situation. In a word, Chicago has not really accepted the challenge of our contemporary condition but is, willy-nilly, a helpless reflection of the same. But from the Sallence which its experiments have conferred on the basic issues, much help can be gained towards establishing a college which would not be a carbon copy of the confusions of the great society. Because there are many people at Chicago, as well as many more who are interested in Chicago, who earnestly desire such a new college, this effort to focus the causes of failure was undertaken.