Appeals to precisely the same dull audience vitiated the quality of Goldsmith, Scott, and Dickens. And Jane Austen’s clearcut superiority is at least partly owing to her not bothering to penetrate this Philistine complacency. These are simple rhetorical judgements. Yet the Chicago dialecticians eschew them as incompatible with Aristotle’s Poetics. The critic knows very well after a few pages that the slack relations which Fielding sets up between the reader and the episodes and himself will persist throughout. Now it is this set of relations, the quality of these dramatic tensions, which constitute “style”. Diction trots far behind. But in the College [12] there is much talk about Gibbon’s style or Christopher Morley’s style or Swift’s style without any consideration of this set of agent relationships. The result is to leave the student groping amidst intangibilities and irrelevance.