McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

The Failure at Chicago

Looking then at the specified scene from Tom Jones, we find that the sympathies of the reader (and author) are heavily engaged on the side of Mr. Allworthy whose character is one of invariable Pickwickian innocence and imprudence. The scene affords an instance of his spontaneous and unreflecting benevolence, which is very heavily underscored by contrasting it with the excessively prudential and reflective malice of Miss Deborah Wilkins. The entire scene is one of the utmost naiveté. Any dramatic tension which might have been achieved by economy and restraint is dissipated by verbosity and the heavy-handed ear-pulling of the reader by Fielding. For Fielding doesn’t trust his reader to provide either perception, wit, or judgement. His appeal, therefore, is frankly to a semi-literate group of non-conformist tradesmen who might be expected to adopt the attitudes of Miss Wilkins unless given a rude thrust in the direction of intellectual and moral honesty.