McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

The Failure at Chicago

Tom Jones is a much discussed book at Chicago. It is regarded as having an excellent plot and as being a literary product worthy of serious regard. But it is not so much “plot” in the sense of the felt life and vision, observable in its various scenes, as “plot” in the sense of an ingenious and consistent schema imposed on a group of characters that guides the discussion. In this latter sense Tom Jones affords a field-day to the dialectician. And one can best indicate the irrelevance. of dialectical abstraction of the “plot” from that novel by [11] illustrating a more relevant way of discussing the book. Thus in any particular scene, say that of Mr. Allworthy and the Foundling, the critic has to consider the author-reader relation, as well as the author’s view of his own work. Basic critical consideration, therefore, must ask what qualities of mind does the author assume in his reader for the enjoyment of his scenes? How much experience and how much alertness of judgement? For quite laborate dialectical structures are compatible with banal adventures and an adolescent level of emotional appeals, as is obvious in popular fiction.