McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

The Failure at Chicago

When Aristotle says that metaphor is the test of a poet since it can’t be taught, or even when he indicates the analogy of improper proportion functioning through metaphor, he doesn’t in any way sharpen the perceptions or extend the experience of the reader of a poem. Thus Aristotle’s discussion of metaphor can in no way facilitate awareness of the rich life of a line like “multitudinous seas incarnadine”, for the life of the line is everywhere in it and in the play from which it comes. And whether a particular metaphor is efficient in embodying and [7] advancing the special conflict of the poem is not a question for which there is any ready-made answer. The answer can only grow from a complete exploration of all the life and coherence of the poem itself. And this fact, which for the critic is primary, had no interest for Aristotle. Of course, he would have agreed with the critic, and pointed out how their purposes were diverse. However, the sense in which “plot” is primary for Aristotle (as when he says that a poet will be more the poet of his plots than of his verses) at least indicates the criterion on which the critic founds his judgement of the value or nullity of a poem, or any work of art.