McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

The Failure at Chicago

How very remote this opportunism is from the method of the Chicago critics will shortly appear. Meantime the obvious fact should be stated at once, that while Aristotle carries us abstractly by his concepts of “imitation” and “plot”, to the intrinsic character, not only of tragedy but of all art, nobody was ever the better maker or critic of any work of art for having read the Poetics. (The converse is notoriously not true.) Yet it is a prime assumption of Professors McKeon and Crane that the dialectical procedure of the Poetics with its abstractions of plot, style, scene, diction, etc. affords a valid method for considering poems. Nothing could be less Aristotelian. Yet it is this assumption which leads the Chicago critics to label all divergent procedures as “platonic” and “dialectical”. This strategy, born of confusion, has bred further confusion and inspired some supererogatory heart searchings among natural critics.