McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

The Failure at Chicago

It is the critic’s plenary function to show by exploration how poems differ in character and value precisely in terms of “plot”. That is to say, in terms of the amount of felt life and action which is manifest in them. Poems aren’t about something. They do something. All poems tend to be dramatic, therefore. So that the critic is always asking the question, “what is the poet doing at this point?” not “What is the poet saying?” Thus, the crux of Professor Olson’s essay on Yeats’s Sailing to Byzantium exhibits a major evasion when he says that “to attempt to find a plot in a lyric would be a profitless if not impossible task. ” He is at pains to abstract its logical structure, and begins his consideration of the poem by a paraphrase of its argument, concluding: “There are thus the following terms, one might say, from which the poem suspends”. The oppositions within the poem he considers within these terms, as though they were embedded in propositions. Having reduced the poem to statements or propositions, he proceeds to analyse then dialectically, easily arriving at the preconceived view that this “lyric” exhibits “a certain formal collocation of terms which is referable to nothing outside itself and may be called the soul of the poem in the sense in which Aristotle calls plot the soul of tragedy.” This kind of “lyric” is static, abstracting from “motion and change” says Professor Olson, whereas tragedy, epic, and comedy are dynamic because imitations of human actions. The principle of this kind of lyric is a tissue not of events but of ideas [8] and “the ordering of the poem” is done not “by necessity and probability, by the antecedents and consequents of action, but by dialectical priority and posteriority.”