McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

The Failure at Chicago

For example, Aristotle’s Poetics is a basic work with Professors McKeon and Crane. Now what saved Aristotle from writing a mere dialectical description presenting a nature-morte, or a catalogued museum of poetic objects, was the fact that his dialectical procedure was not only modified by considerations of generic culture but was directed by a metaphysical interest. “Imitation” and “plot” are used by Aristotle in a sense to be defined by his physics and metaphysics. Of course, if you wish to discuss an art or science without engaging in them you must employ dialectics, says Aristotle, “for it is impossible to discuss them at all from the principles proper to the particular science in hand…” (McKeon’s Aristotle, p. 199). Since Aristotle doesn’t discuss poetry as a poet but [as] a metaphysician, he employs dialectics as his means. But the poet [6] doesn’t discuss poetry, as a poet. And the natural critic doesn’t discuss poetry but engages the perceptions and judgement of himself and the reader in active contact with it by any and every means which may suggest even a temporary relevance or effectiveness. In fact, there no more exists a critical method than a poetic method. Both poet and critic are essentially opportunist, one using a variety of means to make something, the other using a variety of means to focus the perceptions and judgement of himself and the student on the thing made.