McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

The Failure at Chicago

[5] Without quibbling, then, there is no question in their minds of the curriculum providing content or furniture for the human mind. For them a book is not nutriment. It is bone to sharpen the teeth. A challenge to the dialectical method. A book is approached not as an experience but as a problem. It is not a world to be explored but a collection of arguments and strategies to be pinned to the mat. For the dialectician there is simply no sense in the question “Is it true or false?” or “Is it good or indifferent?” Because his method is essentially that of probable argument and [his] description can describe the true or false, the good and bad, equally well. In advance, metaphysics is ruled out by Professors Adler and McKeon, just as poetic is by Professor Crane. Thus Professor McKeon’s “Philosophic Bases of Art and Criticism” is excellent as a description of the ways in which poetic has been viewed in its relation to other activities and other modes of knowledge. But it is not concerned to discover the nature or function of poetic either intrinsically or in social education. For dialectic analysis and description can never be a means of discovery except in strict subordination to metaphysics. Divorced from metaphysics or presuming to control metaphysics, it makes the mind a week-end guest in any and every home of ideas, whence it departs to record the courtesies encountered, but without having experienced any of the dynamics of the situation.