Here again events were being recalled from a remove of more than 40 years. Sirluck was a friend of McLuhan (they edited a Chicago University Press series together) and was a fellow ‘Winnipigeon’. But he had doubtless given little thought in the interim to the matter and no longer had much recall of it. The proposal was less than 3000 words, had no mention of the supposed ‘cadre’ and was not necessarily aimed at the University of Chicago.