Marchand’s description of McLuhan’s 1947 proposal to Hutchins following their 1946 meeting is particularly uninformed:
McLuhan returned from Chicago with more than his usual share of optimism, sat down, and wrote a 10,000-word brief expanding on what he had said at the meeting. Ernest Sirluck, a colleague at the University of Toronto who saw that brief, was amused many years later to note that it “was an enormous piece of special pleading, the most blatant preaching for a call.” McLuhan, in a not so subtle fashion, urged Hutchins to hire him and a few friends to take over his program in the humanities. As McLuhan wrote to one of those old friends from St. Louis, Felix Giovanelli, Hutchins was being offered a plan to revamp his university that would allow McLuhan, Brooks, Muller-Thym, Giovanelli, and others to form a cadre of New Critics and like-minded metaphysicians on his campus. The “circle of fine intellects” McLuhan had been dreaming of since his undergraduate days in Manitoba would be given an institutional power base and institutional prestige.