McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

McLuhan on Mumford 1

Personally, having found the utmost ambiguity in all human technologies, and having never discovered a fixed position from which to view or measure them, I have settled for studying their on-going effects [which are] their users; for the users are inevitably the “content” of all of them. (1)

McLuhan has ‘on their users’ here, not ‘which are their users’. The problem with ‘on their users’ is that it gives the impression that the users are already there before they are effected (not affected!), that the effect of a technology is simply an addition to them. “This assumption of ‘content’ and ‘added’ factors such as human technologies, (is) the typical illusion of naive visual bias in human perception.” (6) McLuhan’s contrasting point is that “human technologies”, aka media, effect or pro-duce the entirety of “their users”, just as chemical elements effect the entirety of any and all physical materials. As he says later in the essay: “Totally different kinds of people result” (13).