Furthermore, at the time of the essay in the early 1970s McLuhan frequently recycled his early work. Sections of his 1943 PhD thesis on Nashe, for example, were reissued in 1970 in the UT journal, Renaissance and Reformation Studies. The 1969 Counterblast recycled pieces from the 1950s including the 1954 mimeographed ‘Counterblast’ and the 1955 ‘‘Historical Approach to the Media’.
At the start of his 2006 edition of the Nashe thesis, W.T. Gordon states that “With the exception of pages 192 to 197 of this edition, published as ‘Cicero and the Renaissance Training for Prince and Poet’ in Renaissance and Reformation Studies VI:3 (1970), pages 38- 42, none of the material has appeared in print previously.” But this is mistaken. Pages 197 to 202 of his edition appeared in a following issue of Renaissance and Reformation Studies (VII:1, 1970, 3-7) in an essay titled ‘The Ciceronian Program in Pulpit and in Literary Criticism’. Further, both McLuhan and his son, Eric, often included bits and pieces from the thesis in their published writings.