McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Neil Turok’s McLuhan

The last sentence, which ended with a laugh at McLuhan’s “wild” lack of academic domesticity (5:20:09), was not retained in the book version of the lectures. But it is plain that for Turok McLuhan’s thought had limitations comparable to, and perhaps in considerable part derived from, Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, whose work Turok characterized as “vague, allusive, and (despite his claims) necessarily unscientific”. (5.25:27; 229)

“Teilhard (…) took a very big-picture view of the universe and our place within it, a picture that encompassed and motivated some of McLuhan’s major insights. Teilhard also foresaw global communications and the internet, writing in the 1950s about ‘the extraordinary network of radio and television communication which already link us all in a sort of etherised human consciousness’…” (5.22:12; 227-228). Turok accepts from Tom Wolfe that Teilhard “motivated some of McLuhan’s major insights”. And it does seem that McLuhan had access to Teilhard’s work in samizdat already when he taught with Teilhard’s fellow Jesuits at St Louis University from 1937 to 1944. However, from the very start of his intellectual life, McLuhan took it that essential reality is plural, as it is in particle physics and chemistry, not singular — and in the domain of ontology there is no greater difference than that between fundamental plurality and fundamental singularity. He was always allergic to ‘omega point’ visionaries like Teilhard and took ‘etherised’ in terms of Eliot’s ‘etherised upon a table’ (from The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock).