McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Neil Turok’s McLuhan

The idea that our communication technologies change us was emphasized by the Canadian communications guru Marshall McLuhan. McLuhan’s 1964 book, Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man, kicked off a wave of interest in the uses of mass media in all forms, from pop music and television to major corporations. McLuhan’s writing is more poetic than analytical, but his basic insight was that the information content of all of these forms of mass media — from ads to games, cars, typewriters (remember, no PCs then!), books, telephones, newspapers, and so on — is less important than their physical form and their direct hold on our behaviour. He summed up this idea in his famous aphorism “The medium is the message.” (5.17:54; 225)

The reading of “the medium is the message” as emphasizing the “physical form” and the “direct hold on our behaviour” of media is exactly contrary to McLuhan. There is no such thing for him as singular and unambiguous “physical form” (just as there is not in chemistry); and all the working of media is indirect because arising from a range of possibilities. Turok regards McLuhan as a “poetic” alchemist, but in fact he was trying to institute something like chemistry in the analysis of human being (construed verbally).