McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

McLuhan on Havelock’s mimesis

How can humans remain the same (as the chained condition of the prisoners in Plato’s cave may be taken to represent) even when they seem to been utterly trans-formed?

A clue to this question is given in Take Today (10-11): “the artist by retracing the processes of cognition (mimesis) bridges the world of sense and the world of awareness.” Here mimesis is not a means of communication limited to oral cultures, but a means of tracing and retracing “the processes of cognition” in all cultures and all individuals whatsoever. In Plato’s cave, for example, all of the prisoners, including the ‘artistic’ one who is to became free, would undergo (or trace) “the processes of cognition”. But only the freed prisoner would re-trace them.
Tracing is enacted in the katabasis of all the prisoners who go down the passage-way into the cave where they will be shackled to shadow experience determined by the cave’s wardens (by the sort of fire they maintain, by the particular puppets they parade to cast the shadows seen by the prisoners, by the conversations they have among themselves which are overheard by the captives, etc). The “artistic” prisoner who is able to free himself painfully re-traces the passage-way in the anabasis of going back up it. Through such a moment of freedom he learns how experience is generated through the mechanisms of the cave or through exposure to the outside world, therefore of its fundamental plurality given such different types of it, therefore what experience is through “detachment of (any one experiential) figure from (experiential) ground“. Hence, in Havelock’s words, the freed prisoner’s artistic demand that humans “should separate themselves from (their experience) instead of identifying with it; (and that) they themselves should become the ‘subject’ who stands apart from the ‘object’ and reconsiders it and analyses it and evaluates it, instead of just ‘imitating’ it.” “They should examine this experience and (…) think about what they say, instead of just saying it.” (Preface to Plato, 47, cited at Laws of Media, 16-17, as given in full above.) But this artistic moment of freedom is no more common in visual experience than it is in acoustic. Whereas the imperative need is to perceive both types at once as possibilities, hence also a third type of their grounded complementarity, humans overwhelmingly prefer to chain themselves to one of them. In Plato’s allegory, the artistic prisoner who attempts to free the chained captives is attacked by them and killed. Joyce’s nightmare of history is the result.