Behind this contrast in basic postulates between Hutchins and his opponents there is a long history. What makes the explanation of the conflict rather difficult is the fact that while the [rhetorical] position of Hutchins is recognizably that of Isocrates and Cicero, the position of men like Dewey is not [obviously] like that [dialectic] of Plato and Aristotle. Nevertheless, I think it can be shown that Dewey and the experimentalists are lineally descended from Plato and Aristotle via William of Ockham and Peter Ramus. My explanation of the modern quarrel is in terms of the old quarrel between the grammarians and rhetoricians on the one hand and the dialecticians on the other hand. It is the quarrel begun by Socrates against the Sophists, from whose ranks he came.
It may be wondered if McLuhan put forward these repeated dualisms on account of confusions in his own mind or as a strategy to prompt consideration of his “ancient quarrel” thesis. Perhaps both! A further question for future research: how far was McLuhan influenced by his ‘agrarian’ friends like Cleanth Brooks and Allen Tate towards a fundamental dualism and away from the threefold of the ‘ancient quarrel’? In the two volume Literary Criticism: A Short History (1957) by Brooks and his Yale colleague, William Wimsatt, a pointer to McLuhan’s 1943 PhD thesis appears in its preface: “A more or less pervasive debt in several chapters to a manuscript book by H.M. McLuhan concerning the ancient war between dialecticians and rhetoricians is here gratefully acknowledged and is underscored by the quotation, following chapter 4, of two substantial excerpts from published essays by Mr. McLuhan.” (Emphasis added.) The excerpted essays were ‘Edgar Poe’s Tradition’, Sewanee Review, LII (January-March, 1944) and ‘Sight, Sound and the Fury’, Commonweal, LX (April 9, 1954).