McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Marchand on McLuhan and the University of Chicago

McLuhan dreamed of various projects. One of the more exciting resulted when Cleanth Brooks asked him to visit the University of Chicago, where Brooks had just spent six months as a guest professor. Brooks had left that university disappointed in its rigorously “logical” approach to literary criticism. Robert Hutchins, then president of the university and ally of Mortimer Adler in the Great Books approach to education, had asked Brooks, whose reputation as a literary critic was then rising steadily, to speak to him personally about what might need to be changed. Brooks agreed on condition that McLuhan accompany him. Brooks had been enormously impressed by McLuhan’s Cambridge thesis and its historical review of the trivium. That account, he felt, had a direct bearing on what was wrong with the University of Chicago.
In June 1946 McLuhan went to Chicago with Brooks and argued the case for change. Basically he told Hutchins that if he wanted to produce graduates who were capable of “learned eloquence” instead of mere technical expertise — as Hutchins had told the world he was going to do — then he would have to do something about his deans, who were all complete dialecticians, strangers to rhetoric and grammar. “Marshall spoke brilliantly”, Brooks recalls. “He put into what seemed to be very cogent, lucid English, in concise form, what I was thinking in inchoate form after six months of teaching there. He who had never set foot on that campus before had it all beautifully diagrammed.” (90)