Hutchins ultimately resisted his proposal — he was planning to leave the university shortly anyway and had no intention of overhauling it before he departed. McLuhan was left to take revenge by writing an essay, never published, denouncing the University of Chicago’s instruction in literature. In that essay, McLuhan cited, with devastating effect, some examples of multiple-choice questions on Hamlet and Tom Jones from University of Chicago exams. These examples, he claimed, were symptoms of the university’s “naive rationalism”, the kind of rationalism that reduced literature to categories and concepts instead of training students to sharpen their perceptions of literature through the analysis of the effects sought by writers. The argument in this essay, like that of his oral presentation to Hutchins, was a variant of a theme McLuhan had pursued since his Cambridge thesis. According to this theme, the rational, or dialectical, mind must be controlled by the other two disciplines of the trivium: by rhetoric, which emphasized the relationship between the author and his audience, and by grammatica, which emphasized verbal analysis. (91)
McLuhan set all this out in specific reference to Hutchins in his ‘Ancient Quarrel in Modern America’ essay which appeared in January 1946, 5 months before the meeting with Hutchins. Did he bring an offprint of this paper to the meeting with Hutchins?