McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

McLuhan’s health 1957-1967

Ted Carpenter, ‘That Not-So-Silent Sea’, 2001
Marshall asked me to join him at Fordham. Thanks to [Howard] Gossage’s obedient journalists, he was now internationally famous, the world’s first celebrity scholar. He was also very ill. A brain tumor was removed. Warmth and brilliance faded. I recall a moment backstage before he faced an audience of executives. He called for “the book”. “The book” was A Thousand and One Jokes for All Occasions. Several were chosen at random and read to him. He laughed at each, though all were awful. In the end that didn’t matter: he mixed up punch lines, leaving his audience thoroughly perplexed. One listener asked for help in unraveling what he assumed was a deliberate riddle. Others dismissed the speaker as fraudulent or mad. Yet even in the worst scenes, there could be wit. (…) The Fordham effort collapsed. Marshall returned to Toronto. (…) The exuberant, witty rainmaker was now a wary, irritable jukebox reciting old phrases in random order. (…) It was so different when we first met, at his home in a great old house, once St. Mike’s infirmary. He stood before the fireplace, Corinne beside him, the fire bright, the two of them tall, extremely handsome, she regal, he witty, punning, quoting jazz lyrics, classics, Yeats, headlines, slang, ads, a Joycean display, then singing, not McCormack, but full of fun.

Here Carpenter attributes how McLuhan’s “warmth and brilliance faded” to his brain operation in 1967. But elsewhere he related this change to McLuhan’s stroke in 1960: “Marshall had a seizure (…) and it changed his personality (…) Marshall was a changed person after that stroke” (‘On McLuhan and Explorations’, cited above). Fitzgerald (also above) concurs: after his 1960 stroke “the man who was a robust and animated specimen has turned into an old man overnight. His nervous intensity’s more pronounced. He’s incapable of relaxing for more than five minutes at a stretch.”