When I wrote The Mechanical Bride some years ago [1946-1950] I did not realize that I was attempting a defense of book-culture against the new media. I can now see that I was trying to bring some of the critical awareness fostered by literary training to bear on the new media of sight and sound. My strategy was wrong, because my obsession with literary values blinded me to much that was actually happening for good and ill. What we have to defend today (…) must be (…) analytical awareness of the nature of the creative process involved in human cognition. For it is in this citadel that science and technology have already established themselves…
‘Sight, Sound, and the Fury’, Commonweal, 60:1, April 9, 1954. McLuhan’s confession here is that his “obsession with literary values” amounted to an unconsidered reduction of the plurality of media to the single medium of literacy. It was somehow entitled to judge them. This “blinded (him) to much that was actually happening for good (even in the new media) and ill (even with literacy)”. “The creative process involved in human cognition” followed immediately since cognition could not take place without deciding among the plural possibilities of media, aka, without the exercise of “the creative process”. Importantly, exactly this criticism had been directed by McLuhan’s mentor in Toronto, Harold Innis, against the 1947 committee report chaired by Robert Hutchins, A Free and Responsible Press (University of Chicago Press, 1947) in a 1949 review of it: “We might ask for separate consideration of the radio, newspapers, motion pictures, magazines, and books rather than a general blur to the effect that whereas the word ‘press’ is used in the publications of the Commission, it refers to all these media (citation from page 2 of the report), since each medium has its peculiarities and an appreciation of this fact is the beginning of a study of the press.” (Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, 15:2, 1949, 265-266) As McLuhan was only now beginning to see, above all thanks to Innis, this was true of any study whatsoever. A beginning had to be made with the identification of the particular medium at stake and especially with the peculiarities of that medium: the medium is the message. McLuhan would continue to recall this paradigm shift in his thinking around 1950 for the rest of his life: “we have confused reason with literacy, and rationalism with a single technology” (Understanding Media, 1964, 15).