McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

The Failure at Chicago

Before describing the fare offered at Chicago, it may be as well to explain briefly the character of the drama in which Hutchins and Adler have played to capacity houses in recent years. Both Hutchins and Adler have a flair for popular issues. Education in a democracy is basic politics. And it is out of a creditable sense of political relevance that these men have “made news” of education. What I think has not been noticed is that Hutchins and Adler really hold [2] strongly opposed positions. Adler’s differences with current education are merely personal and accidental. Nobody could be less concerned with contemporary or any culture than he. As much as a plastics engineer, he is of “know-how” all compact. A man of method and techniques. A dialectician for whom education can never include training in sensibility or taste. In the complete divorce of thought and feeling he is as unconscious and thoroughly Cartesian as Sidney Hook of Columbia Teachers College. Medieval scholasticism being as much the parent of modern technology as mass education is to all the reflex of the latter. Mr Hutchins, however, is really opposed to these highly abstract methods and stresses. His position largely coincides with the Ciceronian humanism which always characterizes the legal profession at its best. Political wisdom, social conscience, and urbane personal culture will always stand in some sort of opposition to the ardor of dialectical disputation and abstract technology, whether these appear in historical scholarship, business management, or engineering megalomania. There is considerable irony, therefore, in the fact that Mr. Hutchins has chosen as the scene of his reform a university least amenable to it, and for his agents the most gifted of his enemies. For, in a strictly impersonal sense, such able men as Professors McKeon, Crane, and Adler were predetermined agents of opposition to the sort of civic humanism which Hutchins had sought to introduce into an educational program which had long been the household drudge of a commercial spouse.