McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

The Failure at Chicago

Some specific illustration of this last charge will perhaps be the most useful way of spending the allotted space here. For to say that an educational program is based on ratiocination without regard to perception and judgement is to define it as wholly inimical to humanism. That is to say, quite divorced from training in taste or discrimination. The man of method whether he be a lab technician, an administrator, or a literary historian is seldom interested in the modes of a living human order, either past or present. In practice, his perceptions are never trained to respond to the multiple and varied evidences of such life whether in a spoon or a poem. He is invariably a categorizer. A genre hunter. Such men flourish in all times and places; but since Descartes their methods have come to be universally applied to the discussion of the arts, the conduct of popular education, and to politics. Witness the Gallup polls. Thus in the nineteenth century history had to become Cartesian in order to be respectable. And historians sought the “scientific” precision of mathematics while glibly eviscerating their subject of its dramatistic character.