The Aesthetic Moment in Landscape Poetry, 1951
Helped by Rimbaud and Mallarmé, Joyce arrived quickly at the formula of the aesthetic moment (…) as consisting in a retracing of the stages of ordinary apprehension. The poetic process he discovered and states in Stephen Hero is the experience of ordinary cognition, but it is that labyrinth reversed, retraced, and hence epiphanized. The moment of arrested cognition achieves at once its stasis and epiphany as a result of the reconstruction of the stages of ordinary apprehension.
The epiphany or manifestation that is an artistic creation is a “moment of arrested cognition” — “the aesthetic moment” — in two senses. First, it is an achieved “stasis” in the process of poetic creation that marks its end: the artist ‘signs off’ on it. There will be no more “stages” in the “process” of its creation since it is now deemed to be finished. Second, the artistic process can be understood as a replay of “the stages of ordinary apprehension”, but just as much “the stages of ordinary apprehension” can be understood as a foreplay of the artistic process. Regarding human experience in this light, there is at every moment a presentation of possibilities, an assessment of them, and a definitive signing off on one of them (or a compound of more than one of them) that will be the form of the ‘following’ instant of experience. In this view, experience is discontinuous and in “the gap where the action is” artistic creativity is ineluctably implicated. Here experience and the artistic process are plainly correlated with film and when he developed this view McLuhan was in fact studying film theorists like Eisenstein, Zavattini and Balázs.
Now in “ordinary apprehension” this whole process is, of course, utterly unconscious. But it is unconscious in the same sense as the chemistry of wine making was once unconscious. An exacting process had been followed and successfully completed by vintners for millennia, but it was unknown just what was going on in that process. Only in the course of the nineteenth century were the implicated stages of transformation revealed as the new discipline of chemistry developed its insights. So, now, “the stages of ordinary apprehension” are successfully completed by billions of people at every moment and this same success has, of course, been accomplished by humans forever. But we have been and continue to be unaware of what is taking place in it. For McLuhan the conditions of modern technology allow the veil over those processes to be lifted. The medium can at last be the message.