Although there was a certain genius to this strategy, it represented a concession to the very criticism it was intended to deflect. Yes, it might true that he didn’t know how to think as a theorist, but this was because he didn’t want to, because this wasn’t his goal. All he really wanted to achieve was to trick people into the idea that he had any intention to think and theorize. As Eric McLuhan put it in his 2008 essay ‘Marshall McLuhan’s Theory of Communication: The Yegg‘: “Marshall McLuhan did not have A Theory of Communication and he did not use theories in his work.”
But in this same ‘Yegg’ essay, Eric cites Stephen Hawking specifying that we cannot do without theories: “When Stephen Hawking discusses his own theory of communication, it becomes immediately obvious that one function of a theory in the hands of a scientist is to prod reality into revealing itself: ‘we cannot distinguish what is real about the universe without a theory’, he (Hawking) writes. A good, elegant theory will describe a wide array of observations and predict the results of new ones. ‘Beyond that, it makes no sense’, he points out, ‘to ask if (a theory) corresponds to reality, because we do not know what reality is independent of a theory’ (citing Hawking, Black Holes and Baby Universes, 1993: 44).” (Yegg, 28). For further discussion, see Menippean satire 3.