McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

McLuhan as supposed satirist

In response to this criticism and at times outright mockery, the people around McLuhan, led by his son Eric, came up with a defense strategy. In this presentation McLuhan was not a theoretician, much less a thinker, he was a Menippean satirist, a jokester, who did not intend his ‘work’ to be taken seriously (at least in an academic way). Those who mocked it had been ‘taken in’ by his professorial ‘put on’. More, such satire and joking were not only some idiosyncrasy of McLuhan as an individual, it was the hidden bond between him and much of the western tradition as a whole. Its productions, too, had either been satirical or should have been. The value of McLuhan’s ‘work’ lay in this general deconstruction. He was important and prescient after all, but as a satirist, not as a thinker or scholar.

That this strategy came first of all from McLuhan himself may be seen in his use of it in 1944 (!) in a letter to John H. Randall concerning a Bacon paper he had submitted, unsuccessfully, to the Journal of the History of Ideas: “This Bacon paper was intended as a raid, but not as a raid to set up a scholastic regime — merely a raid to upset a mass of complacent cliché. (…) The main reason for presenting this paper in its present form is not to produce conviction (…) but to get the scholarly world by its ear (…) The only kind of research which interests me is of an unconventional kind…“. See Gordon, Escape into Understanding, 116.