McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

McLuhan on Mumford 1

The antithetic configurations of eye and ear, of civilized and tribal, of literary and electronic cultures, range the entire gamut of human experience and satisfactions and commitments in utterly different ways.
It is important to know all about these divergent [configurations of] experiences before attempting any value judgements. (2)

These “antithetic configurations” are, in the first instance, elementary “patterns of (…) structure” (1) or “ratios”: “ratios among ratios that create con-sciousness” (4). Only secondarily can the effects of these patterns or structures or ratios or media be termed ‘visual’ (meaning an eye/ear ratio favoring the eye) or ‘auditory’ (meaning an eye/ear ratio favoring the ear). It is precisely because he relies on identifiable grounding structures like these “ratios”, rather than on ambiguous figures, that McLuhan can claim: “This is not a value judgement.” (2) As he says in the immediately following sentence: “It is important to know all about these divergent (configurations of) experiences before attempting any value judgements.” McLuhan’s motto, “the medium is the message”, is a summary statement of these points.