McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Neil Turok’s McLuhan 2: on Plato and Maxwell

It is important to realize that in physics today, we have no knowledge of what energy is. (Feynman)

Feynman Lectures on Physics 4.1, italics in original. All great thinking demonstrates ontology (is) from epistemology (knowing) — although, of course, the end of the demonstration must be to reverse this implication so that epistemology is perceived to be grounded in ontology. Such thinking derives ontology from epistemology by working from the laws of knowing to stipulate what can properly be said. For example, Plato notes in the gigantomachia that a battle between the gods and the giants is ‘always going on’. Each of the two battles the other in an attempt to show that ‘everything’ belongs to their side of the contest — either to the ideas of the gods or to the matter of the giants. But these cannot properly be said together. For either everything can properly be said to belong only to one of the sides or the other, in which case it cannot properly be said that a battle really takes place between them; or it can properly be said that a real battle takes place between them, in which case everything cannot properly be said to belong only to one of the sides or the other. The philosopher works from this epistemological insight to the ontological conclusion that everything must first of all be ‘both together’. But what ‘both together’ implicates is anything but obvious and is, indeed, the question generating all human being and culture whatsoever.