McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Neil Turok’s McLuhan

The application of such media work to quantum physics is plain, since there is nothing that physicists do (so far as physics is not mathematics) that does not express itself in words and engage with things designated by words. It may be expected, then, that some puzzles in physics are to be solved, in whole or in part, not by exclusive research in physics, but by parallel research in communications.

A striking example of the need for linguistic precision in physics is provided by this passage from Turok: “Parmenides believed that at its most fundamental level, the world is unchanging, whereas Heraclitus (…) believed that the world is in ceaseless motion as a result of the tension between opposites.” (52) But if something is “ceaseless” in some way, it is “unchanging” in that way. At bottom this statement reflects a confusion about time, its singularity and/or plurality and its presence and/or absence of direction. Can physics be got right without demonstrable clarity in such matters?