McLuhan’s 1943 Cambridge PhD thesis noted: “In studying the history of dialectics and rhetoric, as indeed, of grammar, it is unavoidable that one adopts the point of view of one of these arts and the history of the trivium is largely a history of the rivalry among them for ascendancy [in the individual psyche and in society at large]”. Like Lodge, indeed like great thinkers from Plato and Aristotle to Vico, Hegel and Heidegger, McLuhan’s solution to the seemingly insuperable problem of self-reference implicated in this insight (“unavoidable that one adopts the point of view of one of these arts”) was to treat the elementary types of communication as possibilities which human being (construed verbally) never ceases to sift. It is as if all physical material first (when is this?) surveys Mendeleev’s table before (ditto) manifesting itself in this or that way. McLuhan’s claim is that human perception does arise in this way and that this process is subject to rigorous collective investigation. Turok’s image of assessing the checkout lines at the supermarket applies here just as it does in quantum physics.
“According to quantum theory, the world is constantly exploring all of its possible classical states all of the time, and is only appearing to us as any one of them with some probability” (206, not part of the lectures as delivered). Turok explicates the checkout images in terms of William Rowan Hamilton’s ‘principle of action’: “Whereas Newton had formulated his laws of motion as rules for following a system forward from one moment in time to the next, Hamilton considered all the possible histories of a system, from some initial time to some final time. He was able to show that the actual history of the system, the one that obeyed Newton’s laws, was the one that minimized a certain quantity called the ‘action’. Let me try to illustrate Hamilton’s idea with the example of what happens when you’re leaving a supermarket. When you’re done with your grocery shopping, you’re faced with a row of checkouts. The nearest will take you less time to walk to, but there may be more people lined up. The farthest checkout will take longer to walk to but may be empty. You can look to see how many people have baskets or trolleys, how much stuff is in them, and how much is on the belt. And then you choose what you think will be the fastest route. This is, roughly speaking, the way Hamilton’s principle works. Just as you minimize the time it takes to leave the supermarket, physical systems evolve in time in such a way as to minimize the ‘action’. Whereas Newton’s laws describe how a system edges forward in time, Hamilton’s method surveys all the available paths into the future and chooses the best among them.” (2.19:28; 62-63) In his lecture, Turok cashed “the best among them” as “the least action path among them”. In these terms, McLuhan’s idea of individual or social identity is that it is a trajectory of ‘best’ choices (but not necessarily a trajectory of “least action” — as demonstrated by every new idea that has ever been conceived, where language itself is the unsurpassable example of such novelty.