McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Neil Turok’s McLuhan

When McLuhan studied as an undergraduate at the University of Manitoba beginning in 1928, the professor who became his mentor there, Rupert Lodge (nephew of the physicist, Sir Oliver Lodge), introduced him to ‘comparative philosophy’. This was an investigation of the inherently ambiguous universe of philosophical speculation in terms of fundamentally different types. Then, when McLuhan arrived at Cambridge in 1934 he found the English school there, especially in the persons of I.A. Richards and F.R. Leavis — themselves greatly influenced by the poetry and prose of T.S. Eliot — fascinated by the phenomenon of linguistic ambiguity. McLuhan’s lifework became the question whether fundamental types and their associated properties might serve to ground a new investigation of human being (construed verbally) in all its multifold manifestations — “everything from individualism to bureaucracy to nationalistic wars, peptic ulcers, and pornography”, as Turok laughingly has it.

Of course, Turok was not endorsing McLuhan here. In fact he was aiming to debunk, via reduction to comical absurdity, the very idea of a genus of sciences that would investigate all the myriad varieties human being. But compare Turok on his own field: “Maxwell’s discovery (…) provided a simple, precise description of a vast array of phenomena: the spark from a brass knob on a cold morning; the signals that traverse our nerves or make our muscles move; lightning strikes and candlelight; the swing of a compass needle and the spin of an electric turbine.” (46)