McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Neil Turok’s McLuhan

Consider a spectrum of art/science ratios stretching between ‘all art’ at one of its ends and ‘all science’ at the other. “Art and science in equal measure” would be the spectrum’s centre-point. On the ‘science’ side of the spectrum, art/science ratios moving away from the balanced centre would favor ‘science’ more and more relative to ‘art’. On the ‘art’ side, ‘art’ would be favored in art/science ratios in the same gradually increasing way relative to ‘science’. Each side would terminate in the monolithic dominance of either only ‘science’ or only ‘art’ in the collapse of the art/science ratio itself. At these extreme ends of the spectrum, one of the ratio poles, either ‘science’ or ‘art’, would overwhelm the other and entirely subsume it.

It is thought-provoking how Turok’s spectrum of scales is isomorphic with such a spectrum of ratios: “All the indications are that the universe is at its simplest at the smallest and largest scales: the Planck length and the Hubble length. It may be no coincidence that the size of a living cell is the geometric mean of these two fundamental lengths. This is the scale of life, the realm we inhabit, and it is the scale of maximum complexity in the universe” (5.11.33; 256). ‘Mean’ here is exactly McLuhan’s ‘medium’! But for McLuhan, of course, ‘mean’ and ‘medium’ are ineluctably plural as means and media and it is precisely this plurality which their spectrum sets out as a kind of Mendeleev’s table of meaning.