McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Neil Turok’s McLuhan

McLuhan’s “the medium is the message” is not primarily about “the uses of mass media” at all. Instead, it is the suggestion that what we take to be self-standing content, like ‘art’ or ‘science’, is in fact a property or effect or message of the medium silently presumed with them. Indeed, before them. So when Turok describes Leonardo as “combining art and science in equal measure”, this is not the same ‘art’ and ‘science’ that he imagines as opposed in Teilhard and McLuhan. These terms are like colors in chemistry where it is a matter of sorting elements and properties.

Cited above from 5.17:54 and 225. Turok is not wrong in observing that McLuhan repeatedly discussed mass media, however, just as he frequently turned to the perceptual senses, especially sight, hearing and touch. But thinking like all conversation whatsoever needs to locate itself somewhere! Even a thinking which is not about particular somethings, but about the varieties of all particular somethings, namely ontologies, must nonetheless situate itself in some particular context. For every interlocutor with whom it would communicate is necessarily located in some particular context. The miracle, as McLuhan said, is that communication nonetheless occurs at all. Furthermore, as has been true of all thinkers in these heights at least since Plato, McLuhan had the problem, beyond that of communication in general, of how to introduce a thinking that implicated seemingly insuperable problems of self-reference and infinite regress (to name but two). And although he became a world-famous talking head, and worked tirelessly on his own as well (as testified by the enormous mass of unpublished writings he left behind him), this was a problem he never solved. His discussions of mass media and of the senses were not able, in the end, to thread the labyrinth of ambiguity which was his central aim and occupation.