McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

McLuhan on first meeting Innis 2

McLuhan’s dating his initial meeting with Innis to 1953 is wildly mistaken, not only because Innis died in November 1952. As set out in McLuhan on first meeting Innis 1 the two had been personally acquainted since at least 1948 — well before Innis “was already ill”. And they had known of each other, arguably from 1936 (when papers written by them appeared in the same issue of the Dalhousie Review) and with certainly from 1945 (when McLuhan wrote two letters to Innis from Assumption College in Windsor). These same considerations of course also put paid to McLuhan’s unaccountable assertion that “I never had any inkling that such a person was on the campus”.

Tom Cooper’s recently (May 2025) published Wisdom Weavers includes a letter from McLuhan to Innis from June 6, 1945 (!):
“Dear Professor Innis, It is pleasant to write to one who is so much admired and spoken of by my especial friend W.T. Easterbrook. Dr Phelan writes that you would like to know the names of some of the men I am to visit this summer in connection with my book on cultural dichotomy in the United States. Let me first mention those I have visited within the past six weeks of travel. First, Fred Millet of Wesleyan University in Middletown, Conn. Then Sigfried Giedion in New York (author of Space, Time, and Architecture). Then Cleanth Brooks and Robt. Heilman of Louisiana State U. in Baton Rouge. I have been at work on this job for some time. It is moving into its final phases. Cordially yours, Marshall McLuhan”. In passing, Cooper also mentions “a previous letter from McLuhan” to Innis, apparently from earlier in 1945. It therefore seems that the personal connection between Innis and McLuhan, doubtless mediated by Easterbrook, was almost a decade older than McLuhan would repeatedly recall in the late 1970s. The reference in McLuhan’s letter to his “book on cultural dichotomy in the United States” could have been to any of three different manuscripts McLuhan was working on in the 1940’s: Illiteracy Unlimited, a never published collection of his occasional essays; Typhon in America, also unpublished; and The Mechanical Bride, which was ultimately published in 1951. As usual, McLuhan had multiple titles under consideration for all of these.