McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Whitehead in McLuhan

Francis Bacon, Ancient or Modern? 1974
A.N. Whitehead, while perceiving that Bacon “is outside the physical line of thought which finally dominated the century” has no way of clarifying his observation that: “Bacon’s line of thought (…) expressed a more fundamental truth than do the materialistic concepts which were then being shaped as adequate for physics.” (Science and the Modern World, London, 1938, p. 56) Quite simply. Bacon’s humanist and grammatical approach to the page of nature and the book of creatures makes for “a conception of organism as fundamental for nature” (Ibid., p. 130).

The references from the 1938 edition of Science and the Modern World are from McLuhan. It is probable that most of this 1974 essay was written in the early 1940s when McLuhan was studying Bacon at SLU in the contexts of writing his own PhD thesis on Nashe and advising the PhD thesis on Bacon of Maurice McNamee. A St Louis Post-Dispatch story from August 10, 1997, ‘McLuhan’s Two Messengers — Maurice McNamee and Walter Ong’, recalled this time from more than 50 years before: “McNamee also had McLuhan as a dissertation director, and he soon found out just what the Canadian-born, Cambridge-educated ‘Mac’ meant by ‘direction’. ‘Mac’s directing of my dissertation consisted of coming into that building right over there, plopping himself down on the bed, and talking for three hours a night about his own studies’, McNamee said through a fit of laughter. ‘He was working on his own dissertation, but he encouraged me to use his methods on my work (on Bacon). So in the end, it was a perfect pairing’.”