McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Lodge’s Questioning Mind

The function of knowledge, for both realist and idealist, is to enable us to know, to understand reality, primarily for the sake of knowing, and only secondarily for the sake of practical advantages. Both schools believe that the practical advantages only come if we persist in treating them as strictly secondary: if, like Pasteur or Madame Curie, we concentrate wholeheartedly upon the theoretical problem of discovering what the objective, factual side of experience really is, in itself. For pragmatists, on the contrary, such an ideal is remote and unattainable; it is formulated without due regard to the conditions of human life, and is to be set on one side as a mistake. To know ‘for the sake of knowing’ seems, to a pragmatist, a vicious abstraction. [84] We should acquire what is called ‘scientific knowledge’ — which is a tissue of essentially practical solutions of problems fundamentally practical, of biological and social significance — not ‘for knowing’s sake’, but for its practical values, ‘for the praise it gets, the gain it brings, the love it breeds’, as Browning puts it, as well as for its sheer efficiency. The advertisements of libraries of literary and scientific ‘classics’, which depict the prudent purchaser as the happy centre of a social gathering, attracting by his literature and his wit all whom he desires to attract, illustrate this idea of the function of knowledge, namely: success.