The limitations of knowledge present difficulty to our attempt at a brief statement. Realists tend to recognize no theoretical limits to knowledge. We cannot, they urge, tell beforehand what we shall be able to discover, and what not. Once we have analysed down to simple ideas, and can proceed to construction, there seems to be no place where we can draw a line and say: ‘Thus far and no further.’ The future of knowledge is a future in which only advance, unlimited possibility of progress, can be predicated, provided that strict [85] adherence to cautious methods is observed. Idealists, on the other hand, once they have constructed the outlines of their absolute system, have great difficulty with the ‘subject-object’ relation. Knowledge for them is always knowledge-for-a-knower, never just knowledge-in-itself. The knower constitutes a definite limitation upon knowledge. If we regard knowledge as a picture, it is a picture which requires a spectator. The knower is always the spectator, and can never fit himself into the picture; and yet, with him left out of the picture, the picture can hardly be true to the whole of experience. This fundamental dualism, this splitting up of experience into a subject and an object, which have no meaning apart from one another, and yet resist complete unification, remains a serious difficulty for idealists. Pragmatists, however, regarding the idea which idealists set before themselves as a vicious abstraction, a self-made puzzle to which no solution is theoretically possible, confine themselves to the successful solution of practical problems piecemeal, and can see none but practical and temporary and accidental limitations to the efficient solution of all genuine problems which may arise.
Exactly such limitation as the key to knowledge, not its negating futility, will be the central lesson McLuhan takes from Innis.