McLuhan’s 1944 lecture (published in 1946), ‘An Ancient Quarrel in Modern America’, requires analysis in a variety of ways. Here its treatment of Aristotle will be examined. But it is also interesting as an example of McLuhan needing to get out of his own way and of his ‘University of Chicago’ writings in the 1940s. It is also, of course, one of a number of texts in which McLuhan attempted to investigate further the “ancient quarrel” set out in his Nashe PhD thesis from 1943.