McLuhan’s 1944 lecture (published in 1946), ‘An Ancient Quarrel in Modern America’, requires analysis in a variety of ways. Here its treatment of Aristotle will be examined. But it is also interesting as an example of McLuhan needing to get out of his own way and of his ‘University of Chicago’ writings in the 1940s. It is also, of course, one of a number of texts in which McLuhan attempted to investigate further the “ancient quarrel” set out in his Nashe PhD thesis from 1943.
McLuhan himself was the medium (who) is (ie, who receives and retransmits) the message: he served as a medium for information that came to him as ‘light through’. To do this, he had to get out of his own way, namely stop redirecting old ‘light on’ from him (‘the rearview mirror’) which interfered with his reception of the incoming new. McLuhan’s 1951 letter to Innis ends (with emphasis added): “the actual techniques of common study today seem to me to be of genuine relevance to anybody who wishes to grasp the best in current poetry and music. And vice versa. There is a real, living unity in our time, as in any other, but it lies submerged under a superficial hubbub of sensation. Using Frequency Modulation (FM) techniques one can slice accurately through such interference, whereas Amplitude Modulation (AM) leaves you bouncing on all the currents.” (The ‘you’ must become the ‘one’, where the ‘one’ is one possibility out of a spectrum of possible you’s. The condition of a science of human artefacts, including thought, feeling and any and all experience, is that also one’s own thought, feeling and experience be part of the domain to be questioned.) In ‘An Ancient Quarrel’, the conscious message from him concerns the stark either/or dualisms described above. But at the same time the message given to him for focused investigation and extended communication was already incoming in his own writing in such expressions as “the means to wisdom” and “the bond of the state” and especially in the notion that “between the speculative dialectician (…) and the eloquent moralist (…) there need be no conflict.” These all served as variable media-tions of dualities (between ignorance and wisdom, between different interests in the state and between dialectic and rhetoric). McLuhan had to realize, first of all, that messages to him were already there — and then investigate them as a directive given for his life’s work. Indeed, the essential life story of Marshall McLuhan lies in the welcoming access he gave, as well as barriers he imposed, between him and the messages vouchsafed to him as their potential medium.