At the same time, Sigfried Giedion, who met and befriended McLuhan in 1943, tried to interest the University of Chicago in hiring him. And this, too, prompted a renewed interest in Aristotle since influential professors there like Ronald Crane, Mortimer Adler and Richard McKeon were avowed Aristotelians. As recorded in McLuhan’s unpublished essay, ‘The Failure in Chicago’, from the mid 1940’s, McLuhan strongly opposed the views of these professors then. But to do so cogently, he had to take on their understanding of Aristotle and to do that he had to win better knowledge of Aristotle himself.
McKeon was a onetime pupil of Gilson in Paris and the editor of The Basic Works of Aristotle, 1941, which McLuhan owned, “heavily annotated”, and frequently cited in his writings. His annotated copy is preserved in his library at the University of Toronto. As well, several of McKeon’s essays are treated prominently in McLuhan’s 1943 PhD thesis.