McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

McLuhan and Aristotle 4 (Synthesis between Plato and Aristotle)

But the concluding part of the thesis (cited and identified above) briefly refers to the “synthesis effected by St. Thomas between Plato and Aristotle”. Here it appears that “the triumph of Aristotle in St. Thomas” was not a triumph of dialectics over Plato and grammar as may initially have appeared, but, rather, was Aristotle’s triumph as the philosopher of Catholicism — achieved in Thomism via insight into the complementarity (not the identity!) of Aristotle and dialectic with Plato and grammar.

McLuhan read Maritain’s Introduction to Philosophy in his first term at Cambridge, 1934-1935. Here is Maritain’s view of the Stagirite from his ‘Preface’ to that Introduction: “the philosophy of Aristotle, as revived and enriched by St. Thomas and his school, may rightly be called the Christian philosophy, both because the Church is never weary of putting it forward as the only true philosophy and because it harmonises perfectly with the truths of faith, nevertheless it is not proposed here for the reader’s acceptance because it is Christian, but because it is demonstrably true.”