McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

McLuhan on Vico

Incidentally, the suggestion about intellectual self-portraits came to me from reading Vico’s autobiography. With him the problem of intellectual growth had been imposed by the struggle to free himself from Descartes. To-day, the problem is the same. To get free of technological modes which have invaded every aspect of education, of thought and feeling. (McLuhan to John Palmer, November 4, 1946)

The Autobiography of Giambattista Vico, trans. T. G. Bergin and M. H. Fisch, Ithaca, NY,1944. According to Fisch in his Introduction to this volume, Vico’s autobiography was to be one of a whole series of intellectual self-portraits to be published in Naples. In the event, however, his was the only one to appear. Presumably (given his association of Vico with Bacon) McLuhan had been alerted to Vico by his Jesuit students in St Louis (particularly Maurice McNamee who wrote his doctorate on Bacon working initially with McLuhan) with the result that he came to read the Autobiography shortly after the publication of its translation. For McLuhan’s association of Vico with Bacon, see Bacon and Vico. As regards “intellectual self-portraits”, in the mid-1940s McLuhan wrote a series of portraits (of Wordsworth, Coleridge, Southey, Byron, Shelley and Keats) for a volume which he titled Character Anthology. Never published, it is to be found in his papers in Ottawa. But the implications of McLuhan’s insight here go far deeper than his production of a series of “intellectual self-portraits” of particular individuals, however revealing those may be. Instead, the fundamental idea is that every human being has a psychological ‘portrait’ which is potentially just as detailed and rigorous, and just as capable of endless scientific investigation, as his or her chemical one. Further, that such science would supply a new sense of truth which could reground humans after millennia of homelessness. See from 1951 above: “Often noted from Montaigne onward is the growing interest in the anatomy of states of mind which in Giambattista Vico reached the point of stress on the importance of reconstructing by vivisection the inner history of one’s own mind.” (The Aesthetic Moment in Landscape Poetry) The entirety of this post, indeed of this blog, is dedicated to the unfolding of this genial thunderstroke which gobsmacked McLuhan in late 1946.