McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Innis on media revolutions (PEMS 2)

These considerations from Acton and from Innis himself provide clear illustration of Innis’ structuralism. Like Acton, he conceived of freedom as determined by the balance of opposed powers like those of church and state. Either of the two sides acting alone, or even in preponderant power relative to the other, was a formula for disaster. The essential thing was to realize the fundamental need for a plurality of competing forces — including the plurality of that plurality. That is, the twofold plurality of independent factors in ratio — like church and state — itself has a plurality of different forms depending on the multifold configurations of those ratios. The imperative for the analysis of political economy (dual genitive!) was therefore to investigate social realities, like freedom or war, in terms of the range of ratios whose numerator and denominator each required acknowledgement of its self-standing reality — but only in some kind of dynamic homeostatic relation to the other.

Innis on the university in ‘A Plea for the University Tradition‘: “Her traditions and her interest demand an obsession with balance and perspective — an obsession with the Greek tradition of the humanities. The search for truth assumes a constant avoidance of extremes and extravagance. Virtue is in the middle way. There are no cures. Always we are compelled to be sceptical of the proposal to cure the world’s ills. We cannot tolerate the dominance of any individual or of any group.”