McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

McLuhan at the crossroads

The notion at stake is just that of chemistry or genetics where a “pattern laid up in heaven” (the atomic elements in the first, the DNA structure of genes in the second) expresses itself dynamically in and as “the living world”. There is, of course, a fundamental difference between such structures and the physical materials they constitute (even when the latter are of utmost purity), but the two levels, while maintaining their distinction, are also one in any given sample. The answer to the question, ‘what is this?’, must always be given in terms of those elementary structures, but is always also some particular expression of them. Theory and instance are never simply identical (here is the basis of ‘scientific progress’), but each mirrors the other in a re-flection that is essential. First starting in 1958, McLuhan would term the fundamentality of this sort of reflection, “the medium is the message”.

Although it would be absurd to insist that color or smell must be considered along with the elements in specifying physical materials, champions and foes of McLuhan have never ceased insisting that the message must be considered along with the medium in some way. One of the chief things the intelligibility sought by McLuhan had to explain as a “survival strategy” was this universal obtuseness.