though each interpretation [of each the three trivial arts] is impregnable within its own limits, when brought into controversy [between them] the debate is ultimately dialectical. (111)
See previous note. Also, earlier in McKeon’s essay: “But herein lies the whole task of philosophy: the examination by reason of the various theories that have been advanced concerning the nature of things.” (68-69) This is pure Gilson and, as a matter of fact, also McLuhan’s first mentor at the University of Manitoba, Rupert Lodge. For Lodge’s position, see The Comparative Method of Rupert Lodge.