McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

Irish Bull

Our fathers sometimes encountered paradox in the jocular form of the “Irish Bull”: “When you see three cows standing in a pasture, the one that is sitting is the Irish Bull.” (106)

H.P. Kelly, Irish Bulls, 1906, p3: “Supposing there were thirteen cows lying down in a field and one of them was standing up; that would be a bull.”

The Irish bull is mentioned by Heine in his 1834 Zur Geschichte der Religion und Philosophie in Deutschland: “Kant hat also nicht(…) die Dinge unterschieden in Phänomena und Noumena, in Dinge, welche für uns existieren, und in Dinge, welche für uns nicht existieren. Dieses wäre ein irländischer Bull in der Philosophie. Er hat nur einen Grenzbegriff geben wollen.” Decades before Heine’s history, Maria Edgeworth and her father published ‘An Essay on Irish Bull’ in 1802.