Robert Hutchins gave McLuhan’s December 1947 proposal for an “editorial community” to his close University of Chicago colleague, John Nef, for his comments. It took Nef only a few days to report back that he found its central object “little short of idiotic”:
Nef was a long-time friend and correspondent of Harold Innis. He was also a good friend of Sigfried Giedion. Strangely, it was to Nef that Giedion first wrote in his attempt to help McLuhan find a more felicitous position in the academy. For discussion see Giedion to Nef re a “promising young scholar”.