McLuhan’s New SciencesCentral topics · Search

McLuhan and Plato 15: Poe’s Maelstrom and the Phaedo

Havelock’s essay concludes with a consideration of Plato’s description of the waters of the earth from Phaedo 111c-112e. This section of the Phaedo and Poe’s Maelstrom are mutually illuminating and together they supply an outline of what was even then beginning to unfold as McLuhan’s lifetime topic: the soul’s moment to moment katabasis into the fund of “human potentialities” (MB 3) and “potencies” (Innis letter). The fundamental idea is that human beings are at every moment essentially exposed to different media, different basic forms of experience, and that this navigation among media in their plural potentiality (the “worldpool”) is what constitutes the significance, or message, of humans as humans — the enactment of human being (dual genitive). The medium is the massage is the message.

Both the publication of MB and the Innis letter date from early 1951. But nearly all of MB was written in the 1940s and the Innis letter, which was a ‘rewrite’, may have been written in 1950.